The Ultimate guide about Best Crib Mattresses in 2022 for New Borns & Toddlers

Just as the birth of a child brings in a wave of excitement, it also leaves you confused with a million questions:

What crib should I buy? Should I purchase a soft mattress? Is there a specific crib mattress size to adhere to?

Considering that the initial months will consist of your baby spending more time asleep than awake, choosing the best crib mattress is the only way to go. After all, you do want your baby to be sleeping like, well, a baby. 

Fortunately, this buying guide contains all the information you need to make your crib mattress purchase – read on.

EDITORS PICK
9.7
On a Budget

On a Budget

  • Low Price
  • Dual-Sided Cushion
  • Waterproof
OVERALL BEST
            9.3
For Long-Term Use

For Long-Term Use

  • Durable – up to 8 years
  • Waterproof
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Double-Sided
BUDGET PICK
8.5
Innerspring

Innerspring

  • Extra-Firm
  • Double-Sided
  • Anti-Sag

The Crib Mattress Categories

Let’s begin with the basics. If you haven’t ever purchased a mattress yourself, it is crucial to know its type so you can determine the best crib mattress for your child. 

However, if you’re already familiar with them and know your type, you can perhaps skip this section of the guide. 

When choosing a crib mattress, here are the usual options you will find:

Inner Spring Mattress 

These mattresses are built upon a support frame that contains a system of metal wires, steel coils, and springs underneath and a cushioned layer on top. 

While the interlocking provides great support and firmness to the mattress, the cushion offers comfort, making it great for a baby. 

Among all mattresses, these are perhaps the oldest – and maybe priciest – ones. 

Foam Mattress

Foam mattresses are commonly made from Polyethylene Foam. They are durable, lightweight, and relatively cheaper than alternatives. 

These mattresses are well known for their ‘silent’ nature. They barely creak or emit any sound, which makes it easier for parents to lay their child to sleep in the crib without risking a wakeup. 

However, the usage of synthetic foam makes the mattress inorganic and can be a letdown for some conscious parents. 

The Flip Mattress

This one is especially for the kids!

Double-sided mattresses, or flip mattresses as you can call them, feature a 2-in-1 mattress. It has two differently cushioned sides: firm and relatively softer. 

The firm one works great in offering support to infants. Whereas when your child grows into a toddler, you can simply flip to the soft side for the best crib mattress for that age!

The type of mattress you choose depends upon your preferences – in price, materials, and durability. 

Best Crib Mattresses To Buy In 2022

If you’re short on time and don’t need the specifics, here’s a rundown on what we have to say about the best crib mattresses for your baby:

Here are our top picks:

IMAGE PRODUCT PRICE
1. EDITORS CHOICE

Twilight Crib & Toddler Mattress

Twilight Crib & Toddler Mattress Check on Amazon
2. Premium CHOICE

Moonlight Little Dreamer Crib Mattress

Moonlight Little Dreamer Crib Mattress  Check on Amazon
3. BUDGET CHOICE

Flex Cool 2-Stage Toddler & Baby

Flex Cool 2-Stage Toddler & Baby Crib Mattress  Check on Amazon
4. CHEAPEST CHOICE

Premium Foam Crib Mattress

Premium Foam Crib Mattress Check on Amazon
5. ANTIBACTERIAL CHOICE

Organic Lightweight Classic Mattress

Organic Lightweight Classic Mattress Check on Amazon
6. EXTRA-FIRM CHOICE

Newton Baby Breathable Crib Mattress

Newton Baby Breathable Crib Mattress Check on Amazon
7. NON-TOXIC CHOICE

Babyletto Pure Cure Standard Hybrid

Babyletto Pure Cure Standard Hybrid Check on Amazon
8. MINI-CRIB CHOICE

Hiccapop Pack and Play Mattress

Hiccapop Pack and Play Mattress Check on Amazon
9. INEXPENSIVE CHOICE

Sealy Cotton Cozy Rest 2-Stage Mattress

Sealy Cotton Cozy Rest 2-Stage Mattress Check on Amazon
10. TOP-RATED CHOICE

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Mini Crib Mattress

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Mini Crib Mattress

Check on Amazon

How To Choose The Best Crib Mattress 

Even if you’ve been purchasing mattresses for yourself for long, these guidelines are important for you. After all, the needs of a child widely differ from those of adults. 

When deciding a mattress specifically for your child’s crib, always consider the following:

  • Firmness

When a newborn, the baby’s bones are fragile. This makes it incredibly important to have an extra firm mattress. 

Push on a mattress. If it is stiff and certainly not something you would like to sleep on – it probably works for your baby. The firmness helps support the bone development of infants while preventing the risk of SIDS a.k.a. crib death. 

  • Breathability

The best crib mattress is one that offers the utmost comfort to your child. This includes easy breathability and good temperature regulation. After all, you do not want your child to feel too hot or cold unnecessarily. 

For this, innerspring mattresses with a high coil count work well due to the improved airflow.

  • Easy Maintenance 

As parents of a newborn, you probably have enough on your plate. Maintaining the crib mattress should not be another item on your to-do list. 

Mattresses that are waterproof or come with washable sheets can help tone down the maintenance by preventing fear of diaper spills and constant washing. 

  • Safe Materials

After your loving embrace, the crib is the place where your child will be spending most of its time. Therefore, making sure that the mattress is safe to use, is essential.

Some mattresses use organic and toxin-free materials and come with guarantees like the GreenGuard Gold Certification or GOTS. These basically imply that the mattress has been tested for safe usage. 

  • Perfect Fit 

The standard crib mattress size is 27.25 x 51.25 inches. However, to choose the best crib mattress for your little one, it is imperative to ensure that the mattress fits your crib snugly. This protects the child from any injury, suffocation, or SIDS. 

Therefore, even if you have a gap of two fingers – it is two too many. 

Keep these guidelines in mind when shopping for a crib mattress. In addition, we would always advise purchasing a new mattress instead of a used one, as the latter can possess bacteria or any other germs. 

Considering how fragile infants are, new and safe is the way to go for the best crib mattress.  

Our Top 10 Best Crib Mattresses 

To make things easier for you, we have given you the basic guidelines and decision criteria to choose the best crib mattress.

However, that is not all.

We have also compiled a list of the 10 best crib mattresses, fit for varying material preferences, budgets, and materials.   

Have a look at our top picks:

We’ve overtaken the responsibility for you. Here are our top 10 best crib mattress protectors:

EDITORS CHOICE
Twilight Crib & Toddler Mattress

1. Best Crib Mattress on a Budget: Twilight Crib & Toddler Mattress 

Parents on a budget, this one is for you! 

By the brand Dream on Me, the mattress has 88 coils, features a double-sided cushion, is waterproof, and GreenGuard Gold certified. That too, for about $50 – yes, really!

It has a whopping 7800+ reviews on Amazon, with roughly 80% of customers giving it 5 stars. Therefore, it would be safe to say that this mattress is customer-approved.

While the waterproof cover prevents any accidental spills (read: diaper failures) from seeping into the mattress, the easy-to-clean abilities make cleaning the mattress a simple wash and dry concept. 

However, even though the mattress has flipping abilities, they aren’t the best. Which can be justified, given the low price point. The mattress is not the quietest, which is also a slight con for babies who move around a lot in their sleep or tend to wake up at the slightest rustle. 

Pros
  • Low Price
  • Dual-Sided Cushion
  • Waterproof
Cons
  • Known to be noisy

PREMIUM CHOICE
Moonlight Little Dreamer Crib

2. Best Crib Mattress For Long-Term Use: Moonlight Little Dreamer Crib Mattress

Considering how babies grow in days if there’s any baby product that you can use for a long time – it’s already a winner! 

This mattress by Moonlight Slumber is for those parents who have just had their first child and plan on having more or do not wish to splurge on more mattresses as their baby grows.

The Dreamer Crib mattress is dual-sided with a firm face for infants and a plush side for infants. The material is hypoallergenic and waterproof, so you don’t have to worry about spills. Even if something happens, you can use a damp sponge and some soapy water, and the mattress is as good as new. 

The best part, however, is the warranty – up to 8 years. This is true and has been put to the test. In fact, many reviews state how parents were able to use this product for 6-7 years and it remains a child favorite. So, it’s parent-approved! 

The slightly problematic part: the mattress isn’t entirely 52 inches, it’s 51 ¼â€. The slight gap can prove dangerous. 

Pros
  • Durable – up to 8 years
  • Waterproof 
  • Hypoallergenic 
  • Double-Sided 
Cons
  • It is less than 52 inches long

BUDGET CHOICE
Flex Cool 2-Stage Toddler & Baby Crib Mattress

3. Best Crib Mattress of Innerspring: Flex Cool 2-Stage Toddler & Baby Crib Mattress

This one is for the oldies who can swear by an innerspring mattress! 

The Baby Flex Cool 2-Stage Crib Mattress by Sealy comes with 204 premium coils that make the surface as firm as can be. There are vertical steel bars on the sides of the mattress to improve the baby’s posture and prevent sagging – a common problem in long-term mattress usage.

The mattress is GreenGuard Gold certified and features a distinct airy 2-design (hence the name “coolâ€). This promotes ease of breathability for your child as they sleep. 

In addition, dual-sidedness means you can use it during infancy and flip it to a softer side for when your little bundle of joy grows a little. 

The downside – while the mattress is waterproof, it isn’t exactly easy to clean. So, if your child is fond of making a little mess, the mattress can prove high maintenance.

Pros
  • Extra-Firm
  • Double-Sided
  • Anti-Sag 
Cons
  • Not easy to clean
  • A little less than 52 inches long

CHEAPEST CHOICE
Premium Foam Crib Mattress

4. Best Crib Mattress of Memory Foam: Premium Foam Crib Mattress

An inexpensive and highly convenient option, the Premium Mattress by Graco belongs to the mattress-in-a-box category. This means it’s lightweight (barely 11 pounds!) and comes wrapped and rolled in a box.

To expand to full size, you’d need to immediately unroll upon delivery and let it resume shape – which can take about 2 days. But this is the norm when purchasing a foam mattress.

The plus points of this mattress are that it’s GreenGuard Gold and JPMA certified. So, you can be sure that it’s safe for your baby. It’s machine washable and comes with a removable cover. So, in case of “accidents” at night, you can throw the cover in the wash and rest assured of a clean mattress for your child to go to sleep on. 

A minor letdown, however, is the lack of a dual side. The mattress is extra firm on both sides, and therefore, primarily useful for infants. When your bundle of joy grows into a toddler, you might need to switch to a softer mattress.

Pros
  • Firm
  • Lightweight
  • Machine Washable
  • Inexpensive
Cons
  • Takes 48 hours to expand
  • Single-Sided

ANTIBACTERIAL CHOICE
Organic Lightweight Classic Mattress

5. Best Organic Crib Mattress: Organic Lightweight Classic Mattress

We’ve checked the specs of many organic mattresses. But this one certainly took the lead in being the best crib mattress for parents searching for an eco-friendly option. 

The mattress is 100% GOTS certified. It comes with a Polyethylene core with an organic covering in cotton. This is paired with another organic layer that is a lightweight cotton,

waterproof, and easy to wash. What surprised us was that even though the mattress refrains from the usual fire retardants, it completely fulfills governmental flammability conditions in addition to maintaining low chemical emissions. 

If this sounds like your kinda mattress, you will love the next fact: It comes pediatrician-recommended! It abides by CPSC recommendations and has the exact firmness level prescribed for infants.

What prevents it from being the best in the lot – it’s not dual-sided. However, that’s okay since it’s one of the cheapest (and best!) organic mattresses we’ve seen. 

What’s better is that it’s even cheaper on Amazon as compared to the rest of the websites (as far as we know). 

Pros
  • Organic
  • Rightly Firm
  • GOTS Certified 
  • Inexpensive
Cons
  • Single-Sided

EXTRA-FIRM CHOICE
Newton Baby Breathable Crib Mattress

6. Best Breathable Crib Mattress: Newton Baby Breathable Crib Mattress

If your baby is a face sleeper or just finds it difficult to sleep at night, this is the best crib mattress for you! We’ve called it the best in the breathable category because it is exactly that – 100%. 

Featuring breathe-thru technology, the core of the mattress is 90% air. Yes, really. This means your baby can breathe right through it without any fear of suffocation or SIDS.

The mattress is end-to-end washable and hypoallergenic, and what sparked our interest was that even the cover is made of a completely breathable fabric. There is no latex or glue or any sort of springs.

Has the mattress has grown dirty? Unzip the cover, wash it, and put it back on. Your baby will be sleeping (and breathing) as sound as a, well, baby!Another great thing that makes this mattress by Newton a winner in the best crib mattress category is that it’s dual-sided.

That’s probably why it has about 2300+ ratings on Amazon with a whopping 92% consisting of 5-stars. But it’s a tad on the expensive side so purchase it only if you are uncompromising on breathability.

Pros
  • Comes in 4 Colors!
  • Truly breathable
  • Washable
  • Dual-Sided 
Cons
  • Relatively expensive
  • Some people complained of a slight odor

NON-TOXIC CHOICE
Babyletto Pure Cure Standard Hybrid

7. Best Quietest Crib Mattress: Babyletto Pure Cure Standard Hybrid

When deciding what category of “bests†we should assign to this beauty of a mattress, we were torn between two: Quietest or Best Fit. The mattress excels on both ends and is certainly one of the best crib mattresses we’ve come across!

Like many other mattresses, this one’s hypoallergenic and waterproof. However, unlike others, its waterproof cover is unexplainably quiet. So, when your baby twists or turns in the night, the ultra-soft cover won’t emit a single rustle, resulting in a night of undisturbed sleep.

Coming to the fit, the mattress is a complete 52 inches long. Not 51 and a half, or otherwise, making it a perfect match to the standard crib size. Its cover has a zipper closure which also makes it a snug fit. 

This mattress is also GreenGuard Gold certified and is made with 100% recyclable polyester core. It being two-sided also means you can toggle between the firmness level, and the investment is a long-term one. 

The only downside; it’s a relatively high maintenance mattress. It does not wipe off easily, so you’d probably need a machine wash, and it weighs comparatively heavier too at 15 pounds. 

Pros
  • Incredibly quiet
  • Snug fit
  • Dual-Sided 
Cons
  • Requires machine wash
  • Not lightweight

MINI-CRIB CHOICE
Hiccapop Pack and Play Mattress

8. Best Portable Crib Mattress: Hiccapop Pack and Play Mattress

Is your child fond of playdates or a little outside fun? Then you definitely need a portable mattress. Fortunately, we’ve found a lightweight option just for you! 

The mattress by Hiccapop weighs roughly 5 and a half pounds. Therefore, it can easily be lugged room to room or outside your home.

It is 3.25 inches thick with rounded edges that provide great support for the child. So, if your child is playing and decides to do a face-down move – don’t worry. They won’t sink into the mattress courtesy of its incredible firmness.

The mattress is also leak-free, thanks to its ultra-soft jacquard cover. However, in case it does require cleaning, you would have to wash and dry the cover in a machine. 

But that’s a small price to pay for a mattress that is dual-sided and costs less than $100 – really, we’re not joking. After all, we’ve called it one of the best crib mattresses for a reason.

Pros
  • Lightweight
  • Leak-Free
  • Dual-Sided
  • Under $100!
Cons
  • Requires machine wash

INEXPENSIVE CHOICE
Sealy Cotton Cozy Rest 2-Stage Mattress

9. Best Dual-Sided Crib Mattress: Sealy Cotton Cozy Rest 2-Stage Mattress

If your little bundle of joy is just a newborn, it might be difficult to imagine them as a walking, talking person right now. But that’s exactly what’s going to happen in a few years, and it’s best to be prepared. The first step – get the right mattress

Being proactive in this regard means purchasing a baby crib mattress that has room to grow, i.e., is two-sided. The Sealy mattress offering 2 stages of firmness is a complete steal in this category costing under $100!

The coil-filled mattress has a firm cotton layer on one side which is great for infants, and an extra-plush layer of breathable cotton on the other – perfect for toddlers. When the time comes, you can simply flip the mattress over. 

The mattress is also stain-resistant and waterproof, qualities that you seldom get in a crib mattress at this price. The waterproof lock-stitched binding protects the core of the mattress against leakages and spills. 

However, the mattress is thought to have a foul odor when new, which goes away in an hour or so – so all in all, a great value-for-price product.

Pros
  • Two-Sided
  • Waterproof
  • Stain-Resistant
  • Inexpensive    
Cons
  • Some users complain of a temporary foul odor

TOP-RATED CHOICE
Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Mini Crib Mattress

10. Best Mini Crib Mattress: Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Mini Crib Mattress

Since we wanted to make this guide as inclusive as possible for parents hoping to purchase the best crib mattress for their child, of course, we couldn’t forget those with smaller crib sizes.

After all, not everybody has enough space in the house for a standard-sized crib – and that’s completely fine. 

The Little Dreamer Mini is inexpensive and measures 38x24x25 inches. However, the smaller size does not mean it compromises on quality or features. 

The mattress is waterproof and durable. In case of any spills, you can wipe them off with a damp sponge and lukewarm water with soap. The cover has a stretch-knit fabric that provides a snug fit to the mattress and crib, allowing your child to sleep restfully. 

An aspect that impressed us was that in addition to being double-sided, the mattress also contains arrow tags highlighting which side is good for an infant and which has a plush surface for your toddler. However, some users did complain of the toddler side being too soft – and that’s the only downside we see.

The mattress is also made with CertiPUR-US certified foam and non-toxic wrapping, meaning it’s safe for your child to use.

Pros
  • Mini-Sized
  • Waterproof
  • Easy to clean
  • Dual-Sided and labeled
Cons
  • Some users complain of one side being too soft

Final Verdict 

A baby sleeps up to 17 hours a day. Therefore, it is vital to choose the best crib mattress for your little one. 

You can base your decision on many aspects – breathability, price, size, dual-sidedness, etc. – and our guide provides the best option for that category. 

However, if we were to give a verdict on the overall best crib mattress, it would be the Newton Baby Breathable Crib Mattress (i.e., Number 6). It is comfortable, two-sided, easy-to-clean, and breathable through and through. 

For us, the comfort of the baby triumphs all other things, and the quality of sleep this mattress provides is unmatched!

Frequently Asked Questions 

It’s okay to have questions. In fact, we encourage them! After all, it’s a matter of your life – your child. 

How do I choose a crib mattress?

There are a few factors to ensure when choosing a crib mattress for your baby. Make sure it’s extra firm, a snug fit for your crib, washable for spills, and preferably dual-sided to flip over for toddlers. 

Are crib mattresses universal? 

Almost. There are standard dimensions for a baby’s crib mattress. They usually are 51-53 inches long and 27-28 inches wide.

How do I choose a crib mattress that is safe for my baby?

Make sure of three aspects. 1) The mattress is extra-firm to disallow your child’s face from sinking in and thereby preventing suffocation. 2) The mattress fits perfectly in your crib and there is no space on the sides, preventing SIDS. 3) The crib mattress is made of toxic-free and safe materials.  

What is the cost of a crib mattress?

Crib mattresses can be found in the range $90-$200. Organic and/or innerspring mattresses are relatively expensive and can go up to $400 too. Therefore, the cost depends on the qualities you desire.   

Leave a Comment