Foam vs Spring Crib Mattress: Which One Should You Buy?

If you’re looking around for a crib mattress for your little one then you may confuse to choose between Foam or Spring Crib Mattress and you may be feeling a bit overwhelmed by the number of choices on the market.

If you thought that picking a crib mattress was just a matter of finding a scaled-down version of the mattress on your own bed, then you’re wrong.

Buying a crib mattress is trickier than finding a mattress for adults because babies are so much more sensitive to the chemicals that are used in making standard foam mattresses.

Babies also need firm mattresses to reduce the risk of suffocation. Before making your purchase, you’ll have to look into synthetic vs organic, and a foam vs spring crib mattress.

If you’re stuck on the foam vs spring crib mattress debate, it can help to find out exactly how each type of mattress is made and the benefits and drawbacks of each type.

Doing so will allow you to pick a product that’s best for your baby and suitable for your budget as well.

Foam vs Spring Crib Mattress

1. Foam Mattress

Foam crib mattresses are usually made from polyether or polyester material. In the past, foam crib mattresses were made of polyurethane foam, but the material has since been found to be harmful to babies due to the flame retardant chemicals used to treat it.

Polyurethane releases volatile organic compounds that could have a negative effect on your baby’s health. Today, many manufacturers of crib mattresses no longer use polyurethane, but it’s best to check the label to be safe.

Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib Mattress, Ecru

A foam crib mattress is a good choice if you’re on a budget since it can be a lot cheaper than spring mattresses. The cheapest ones sell for as low as $50, and you can get a high-end one for about $150 or even a bit less.

Foam mattresses are also lightweight and convenient for changing sheets. When buying a foam crib mattress, make sure you get one that’s firm and resilient to cut down on the risk of SIDS.

2. Spring Mattress

A spring crib mattress is made with a set of inner springs covered with foam and cotton to make them soft and comfortable. Spring mattresses often have one side covered with cotton and the other with plastic that’s easy to wipe clean. A mattress with a high coil count is considered better as it makes for a firm mattress with better support.

Spring crib mattresses are considered a more durable option than foam, thanks to their construction. They’re able to hold their shape better over time since the coil and frame provide support and prevent the mattress from sagging and becoming deformed. However, they cost a bit more than their foam counterparts.

In choosing sides on the foam vs spring crib mattress debate, you should take into consideration your needs as well as your budget.

A quality foam mattress is good enough if you want to spend less and want a mattress that’s easy to lift and move around. Meanwhile, if you intend to have more than one child and need a crib mattress that lasts, you might want to invest in a spring model.