Best Pack and Play Crib Mattress

A good pack and play mattress can be a parents’ best friend. After all, it means you can take your baby with you, in complete safety, wherever you go. But when choosing the best pack and play crib mattress, parents tend to miss out on one aspect – comfort. 

Surprised? We were too! 

The top contenders for a good pack and play mattress are often shortlisted on the basis of portability and lightweight qualities. This lack of comfort is probably why your baby is often tossing and turning when he rests in the pack and play when you’re on vacation. 

But don’t worry. After heavily researching the market for baby crib mattresses, we’ve come up with the best that you can purchase separately to make your baby’s pack and play, a haven of comfort.

EDITORS PICK
9.7
PREMIUM

Newborns

  • TPU waterproof layer
  • Washable
  • Tri-fold, with carrying case
  • Life-time guarantee
OVERALL BEST
9.3
Preemie

Preemie

  • Promotes airflow
  • Waterproof and stain resistant
  • Passes flammability tests
  • Greenguard gold certified
BUDGET PICK
8.5
Toddlers

Toddlers

  • Multipurpose tri-fold mattress
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Stain resistant
  • Budget friendly – under 50$!

10 Best Pack N Play Crib Mattress

In a hurry and cannot read the entire guide? Our best pack and play crib mattresses choices are listed below:

IMAGE PRODUCT PRICE
1. EDITORS CHOICE

Graco Premium Foam Baby Crib Mattress

Dream On Me Breathable Play Yard Mattress Check on Amazon
2. PREMIUM CHOICE

Milliard Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic Infant Crib Mattress

Biloban Pack and Play Mattress Check on Amazon
3. BUDGET CHOICE

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Blue Crib Mattress

Hiccapop Tri-Fold Pack and Play Pad Check on Amazon
4. CHEAPEST CHOICE

Kolcraft Pure Sleep Therapeutic 150 Waterproof Baby Crib Mattress

Milliard Memory Foam Pack N Play Mattress Check on Amazon
5. ANTIBACTERIAL CHOICE

Sealy Baby Firm Rest Antibacterial Waterproof Standard Baby Crib Mattress

Hiccapop Dual-Sided Pack and Play Pad Check on Amazon
6. EXTRA-FIRM CHOICE

Serta Perfect Start Dual Sided Premium Recycled Fiber Core Crib Mattress

Spring Spirit Waterproof Soft Bamboo Mattress Topper   Check on Amazon
7. EXTRA-FIRM CHOICE

Serta Perfect Start Dual Sided Premium Recycled Fiber Core Crib Mattress

Dream On Me Coil Play Yard Mattress

Check on Amazon
8. MINI-CRIB CHOICE

DaVinci Complete Slumber Mini Crib Mattress

Organic Dream Pack and Play Mattress Check on Amazon
9. INEXPENSIVE CHOICE

Dream On Me, Orthopedic Firm Foam Standard Crib Mattress

NapYou Pack n Play Mattress Check on Amazon
10. TOP-RATED CHOICE

Delta Children Twinkle Galaxy Dual Sided Premium Recycled Fiber Core Crib Mattress

Milliard Elite Pack N Play Mattress Check on Amazon

How To Choose A Pack And Play Mattress?

Unfortunately, since the standard crib mattresses seldom fit in a Pack and Play, you’d have to make another investment for the best pack and play mattress. Fortunately, this time you’ll know just what you’re looking for, and will be able to make an informed decision:

Right Level Of Firmness

The level of firmness of the mattress depends on your baby’s age. If you have an infant or a newborn, look for an extra firm pack and play mattress. On the other hand, toddlers and older aged children can work with relatively softer mattresses too. We suggest buying one with 2 levels of firmness (i.e., flippable), to save a few bucks! 

Portability

Of course, a pack and play mattress needs to be portable! That’s the entire purpose of it. You will be lugging it around when you visit your mother, take a vacation, or even venture from the baby’s room to the kitchen. If the mattress is lightweight, or better yet, foldable, it’ll become your favorite-most purchase for your baby! 

Easy Maintenance

Ever heard of a child making no mess when they play? We sure haven’t! Pack and Play mattresses are supposed to get dirty. From toys to crayon marks and nibbles of food, you’d find a new stain every day. Therefore, it is recommended that you buy an easy-to-wash or waterproof pack and play mattress.  

Top 10 Best Pack and Play Mattresses

Now that you know the specifics of what makes for a good pack and play mattress, it’s time to get down to business – before your little one wakes up. 

Have a look at our top 10 picks, either of which are bound to leave you satisfied and your baby – ecstatic!

EDITORS CHOICE
Best Crib Mattress For Newborns

1. Best Breathable Mattress: Dream On Me Breathable Play Yard Mattress

When your baby’s playing on the pack and play, you don’t always have the time to babysit constantly. But what if the baby turns facedown and cannot revert to their original position?

If such thoughts keep troubling you, focus on getting a breathable pack and play mattress for your little one. The one by Dream On Me is the best we could find. 

The mattress is specially designed with a breath flow technology that allows maximum airflow and takes away any worries for if your child should have to breathe through the fabric. The mattress also fulfills all flammability tests and comes Greenguard Gold Certified – i.e., completely safe. 

But that’s not all. For a mere $51 price tag, the pack and play pad is of good size, waterproof nature, and dual-sided! Not only will it resist stains and be easy to maintain, but its dual levels of firmness mean you can use it for quite long, or multiple aged children too! 

Yes, the mattress doesn’t fold too easy and can’t fit a mini crib. But on its own or as a pack and play, it’s perfect for infants and toddlers alike!

Pros
  • Promotes airflow
  • Waterproof and stain resistant
  • Passes flammability tests
  • Greenguard gold certified
  • Budget friendly
Cons
  • Doesn’t fold so isn’t a great option in terms of portability
  • Won’t fit a mini crib

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Crib Mattress for Preemie

2. Best Waterproof Mattress: Biloban Pack and Play Mattress

Cleaning up spills and leakages is a usual part of every parent’s routine. But, when you’ve got the Mom’s Choice for Best Playard Mattress 2021 as a waterproof pack and play mattress, you’ve got nothing to worry about. 

First things first, the mattress comes with a waterproof, washable cover secured with a zip. Yes, that’s correct! See a stain? Zip the cover open, throw it into the wash, and zip it back up again. Easy as cake! Featuring a star print and a TPU waterproof layer, the cover is as cute as it is easy to maintain. 

Next – the tri-fold design. This left us in love. Weighing merely 3.58 pounds, the mattress is easy to carry, and its foldability makes it a good fit for most locations and cribs. It’s carrying case also makes it the perfect baby-travel accessory. 

The mattress also features a distinct, non-slip backing design. Which means it stays in place, whether your child is sleeping on it or throwing a full-on tantrum. In-place means safety – always. 

However, some users have complained about slightly varying degrees of thickness of each of the three folds, so that remains a minor concern. 

Pros
  • TPU waterproof layer
  • Washable
  • Non-slip
  • Tri-fold, with carrying case
  • Life-time guarantee
Cons
  • Some users have complained about different thickness of each fold

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Crib Mattress for Toddlers

3. Best Tri-Fold Mattress: Hiccapop Tri-Fold Pack and Play Pad

Since we’re talking about tri-fold mattresses, it only made sense to tell you about the best tri-fold pack n play mattress we’ve found. Full disclaimer – we might seem a bit too excited about the mattress, because it was love at first sight! Here’s why:

This is one of the ONLY tri-fold pack and play pads that come dual-sided, that too for under $50! It’s extra thick at 2.25 inches to provide your little one with the maximum comfort, while being made of CertiPUR-US high-density memory foam which means its quality and durability combined. 

Three folds means the mattress is perfect for on-the-go parents (or children!). Take it to the babysitters, place it onto the crib, use it for tummy-time, makeshift as a changing pad – trust us when we say you can do everything with this Hiccapop mattress!

To make a parent’s life easier, the mattress comes with a hypoallergenic, waterproof, stain-resistant cover too. Can it get any better than this?   

The mattress comes with 8800+ reviews on Amazon, almost 90% of which give it 5 stars! But yes, a little tale of caution: the mattress is designed for standard sized playards. So, you should measure your own before making the purchase to avoid any gaps. 

Pros
  • Multipurpose tri-fold mattress
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Stain resistant
  • Positively reviewed by many
  • Budget friendly – under 50$!
Cons
  • Fits standard sized playards only

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Baby Crib Mattress Two-Sided

4. Best Soft Mattress: Milliard Memory Foam Pack N Play Mattress

In the initial stages, babies require firm mattresses. However, as toddlers or above, they place comfort over everything else. This means a plush mattress is your best bet at keeping the little angel (or monster, haha!) occupied during naptime and playtime. That’s where this soft pack and play mattress shines. 

2-inch think and weighing merely 2.5 lbs, the mattress is made of the highest quality of 100% memory foam. This gives your baby a plush surface that contours according to their body, giving them effortless comfort. 

This isn’t all. The mattress topper is also ventilated to provided cooling relief and therefore is breathable. In addition, it’s cover is hypoallergenic, keeping your baby’s health as a top priority. 

Considering the light weight of the mattress, you can place it into the crib or roll it up, courtesy its Roll-N-Carry feature for eased portability. 

However, remember that this is a soft mattress and therefore not recommended for newborns and infants, or relatively heavy kids who may sink into the mattress.

Pros
  • Ultra-soft
  • 100% memory foam
  • Ventilated
  • Hypoallergenic cover
  • Roll-N-Carry feature
Cons
  • Not recommended for newborns, infants, and heavier children who run the risk of “sinking” into plush mattresses.

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Baby Crib Mattress Portable

5. Best Dual-Sided Mattress: Hiccapop Dual-Sided Pack and Play Pad

If you haven’t figured it out already, Hiccapop’s one of our favorite crib mattress brands. This mattress of theirs is two-sided, featuring one extra-firm side for newborns and infants, and another relatively soft side for older kids.

But the soft side is known to be a little too soft. So, hold onto switching to it under your child is a little older. 

The mattress is 3.25 inches thick, and so provides incredible back support. While its round edges make sure it leaves no gaps when in the play yard or crib. 

The exterior layer of the mattress is a unique blend of cotton and polyester, making it the right amount of soft and effortlessly durable. In addition, it comes with a zippered jacquard cover that is hypoallergenic, waterproof, stain resistant and lead and phthalate-free. In case of any spills or leakages, you can wash the cover in the machine too – another item ticked off a parent’s long to-do list. 

With over 19,000 reviews on Amazon and about 90% of them being positive with a 5-star rating, it’s safe to say that it isn’t only us who’s liked this mattress. 

If you are looking to invest in a dual-sided pack and play mattress that lasts you through the years (and maybe some kids too), this is a great option!

Pros
  • Dual-sided
  • Thick for good back support
  • Zippered cover
  • Waterproof and washable
Cons
  • The softer side is known to be a little too soft
  • Slightly expensive

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Baby Crib Mattress Breathable

6. Best Skin-Friendly Mattress: Spring Spirit Waterproof Soft Bamboo Mattress Topper

We haven’t seen many parents search for the best skin-friendly mattresses for their kids. But this one by Spring Spirit made us wonder what we were missing out on. 

The mattress has one of the softest surfaces you will come across – no joke. Made with smooth bamboo jacquard and high-density foam, the surface is natural, breathable, skin-friendly, and plush to the touch.

If your child has sensitive skin or just generally delicate features, this mattress provides the support they need to grow.

What’s better is that the mattress comes with smooth bamboo cover also. It has a zip and is secured with a TPU Waterproof layer, keeping you protected from “accidents” that are bound to happen with kids around. 

Similar to the Biloban mattress, this one also has a non-slip, backing design. It is tri-fold and comes with rounded corners to fit perfectly into play yards and cribs. 

The topper is also inexpensive and comes with life-time warranty. But of course, remember since it’s a topper, it isn’t the thickest mattress pad out there.

Pros
  • Skin-friendly
  • Natural – made with bamboo
  • Waterproof cover
  • Non-slip backing design
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Inexpensive
Cons
  • Is a mattress topper and therefore roughly 2 inches thick.

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Baby Crib Mattress Hypoallergenic

7. Best Safest Mattress: Dream On Me Coil Play Yard Mattres

Safety needs to be one of the priorities when choosing the best pack and play mattress for your child. Period. Afterall, a mattress is probably the only place where your baby will be spending most time after your lap. This is why the Dream On me 3-inch mattress caught our eye. 

The mattress offers incredible comfort with its coil and foam interior and is Greenguard Gold certified, ticking the first safety requirement on our list. 

The Dream On Me mattress also passes all flammability tests such as the 16 CFR 1632 and 1633. It is antibacterial, hypoallergenic, allows airflow and therefore breathability, and also passes lead and phthalate testing. You can trust the mattress to prevent buildup of mold and mildew.

In addition, the mattress is easy to clean. Simply mild soap and a little warm water an do the trick to swipe off any spills or stains off the cover. Although the mattress is slightly expensive than comparative 3-inch mattresses in the market; but the money is nothing when the matter is of the safety of our children, isn’t it?

Pros
  • Greenguard Gold certified
  • Passes flammability, lead, and phthalate testing
  • Antibacterial
  • Hypoallergenic
Cons
  • Slightly expensive than other 3-inch mattresses

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Baby Crib Mattress Organic

8. Best Organic Mattress: Organic Dream Pack and Play Mattress

For parents that follow sustainability trends and are hoping to switch to eco-friendly products, the pack n play by Organic Dream is incredible to make the shift. 

It is one of the best organic pack and play mattresses we have come across – albeit it is a little on the expensive side.

The mattress is made with breathable, completely baby-safe technology. It has no VOCs, chemicals emissions, or usage of any form of synthetic chemicals. 

The surface of the play pad is 100% organic and completely breathable, leaving you with the peace of mind that face up or down, your child will be safe and sound. The mattress is also Greenguard Gold certified – another feather in its cap. 

If this wasn’t enough, the mattress is dual-sided too! Yes, really! It has two sides with varying levels of firmness which make this rather expensive buy, a worthwhile investment. 

Pros
  • Completely organic
  • Breathable
  • No VOCs or chemical emissions
  • Greenguard Gold certified
  • Dual-Sided
Cons
  • Expensive

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Baby Crib Mattress Affordable

9. Best Travel Mattress: NapYou Pack n Play Mattress

Traveling with a baby is not easy. With different tummy-time and naptime, it’s like the children can sense they’re in a different environment, and most aren’t too willing to cooperate. But there’s one way to prevent those tantrums in the hotel lobby – a travel pack and play mattress. 

The NapYou pack n play mattress, offered exclusively at Amazon, is your best travel companion. It fits the most standard pack n play you’d find anywhere – i.e., the Standard Graco. It features rounded corners which enable a snug fit into the pack n play. 

The mattress is tri-fold and comes with its own carry bag. Ready to travel? Fold it up and place it in the carry-on. Ready for a little playtime? Unfold it and place it in the pack n play. Or you can even consider it as a makeshift sleeping mat. It works both ways.  

The core of the mattress is made with a unique, organic cotton and polyester blend. While it is covered with a food-grade waterproof liner to keep it protected from spills and leakages. 

However, as much as the mattress sounds delightful, it is made of memory foam and therefore does usually take 24-48 hours to expand. 

Pros
  • Tri-fold
  • Snug fit for standard pack n plays
  • Comes with a carry bag
  • Made with organic cotton
  • Waterproof
Cons
  • Takes 24-48 hours to expand since it consists of memory foam

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Baby Crib Mattress Waterproof

10. Best Mattress For Toddlers and Infants: Milliard Elite Pack N Play Mattress

We’re ending our list of best pack and play mattresses with a diverse option, one that fits well for both infants and toddlers. 

This mattress by Milliard, one of the best crib mattress brands, comes highly rated. It has a dual-sided cover featuring 2 levels of firmness: one for infants and the other for toddlers.

If you’ve got multiple-aged children, you can continue switching between the two sides for a mattress that appeals to all, without having to go out and spend your bucks on two different mattresses. 

The mattress has a waterproof cover that is waterproof on both sides and incredibly easy to clean. If you feel the mattress needs a wash, you can do that too with its easy cover removability. 

3 inches thick, the mattress comes CertiPUR-US certified. However, since it’s a topper made with foam, it requires 24-48 hours to expand, so bear that in mind. 

Pros
  • Dual-Sided
  • Waterproof on both sides
  • Washable cover
  • CertiPUR-US certified
Cons
  • Requires 24-48 hours to expand

Conclusion 

Now that we’ve given you a roundup of the 10 best pack and play mattresses we could find, your job of finding the right mattress for your little one has become a mere click and checkout journey. 

For our final verdict, if we had to choose between all the options, we’d tie between two – the Biloban Pack (#2) and Play Mattress and Hiccapop Tri-Fold Pack and Play Pad (#3). 

The two mattresses contain impressive features while prioritizing child safety and remaining within most budgets – a win-win in our case! But of course, each one of these pack n play mattresses is a winner in our eyes!

Frequently Asked Questions 

Can I use my regular baby crib mattress for the Pack n Play? 

Usually, no. Standard crib and standard pack n play sizes are different. Therefore, a mattress that fits your baby’s crib wouldn’t necessarily fit a pack n play. Since the mattress should always be a snug fit with no gaps, we suggest buying a separate pack and play mattress.

How much weight can a pack and play mattress take? 

Most mattresses take up to 30 lbs. Others that have a lower limit are usually lesser in thickness or will have it labelled in description. 

Can I wash a pack and play mattress?

Many pack and play mattress, such as those in our list, contain removable, washable covers that are easy to clean and maintain.

Is it okay to use a Pack n Play as my baby’s crib? 

Yes! A pack n play is much like a crib, just like a bassinet. It’s completely fine to use it for your child’s sleep time. But, that makes it even more important to purchase the right pack and play mattress.  

Leave a Comment