Best Non-Toxic And Organic Crib Mattresses

When choosing baby items, the number one priority for every parent is Safety. This means they mostly look for cribs with high rails, fitted sheets, no pillows, nor any gaps between the mattress and the crib bars, etc. But, what if we were to tell you that a lot regarding the safety of your little angel lies, not above, but within your mattress?

Many mattresses are toxic for children. They may contain harmful fumes, flame retardant chemicals, volatile organic compounds (VOCs), plasticizers, and a lot more dangers. Unfortunately, these can react with your baby’s hormones and impair the mental as well as physical development of your child. 

But certainly not if we can help it. 

Our kids need protection, and that means getting the best organic crib mattress we can find. We’ve seen them all, weighed the pros and cons, and given you a list of the 10 best choices we could discover. 

Embark on a safe, organic purchase journey, one that keeps lurking dangers of the mattress, away from your child.

EDITORS PICK
9.7
PREMIUM

Newborns

  • Breathable with breathe-thru tech
  • Washable 3D mesh surface
  • Allergy-free
  • Dual-sided
OVERALL BEST
9.3
Preemie

Preemie

  • Hypoallergenic
  • Greenguard Gold certified
  • Organic cotton, washable cover
  • No chemical smells
BUDGET PICK
8.5
Toddlers

Toddlers

  • Pocket-Friendly – less than 100$
  • Made with plant-based soy foam
  • Dual-sided
  • Waterproof and stain resistant cover

Our Top 10 Picks For Non-Toxic, Organic Crib Mattresses

There were many types of organic crib mattresses. We have shortlisted the best ones, featuring diverse price points to fit into most budgets. 

Here’s what we loved:

IMAGE PRODUCT PRICE
1. EDITORS CHOICE

Graco Premium Foam Baby Crib Mattress

Naturepedic Breathable Organic Crib Mattress 252-Coil Check on Amazon
2. PREMIUM CHOICE

Milliard Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic Infant Crib Mattress

Naturepedic Organic Lightweight Classic Baby & Toddler Mattress Check on Amazon
3. BUDGET CHOICE

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Blue Crib Mattress

Organic Dream Organic Cotton Lightweight Mattress  Check on Amazon
4. CHEAPEST CHOICE

Kolcraft Pure Sleep Therapeutic 150 Waterproof Baby Crib Mattress

Delta Children Simmons SlumberTime Naturally  Check on Amazon
5. ANTIBACTERIAL CHOICE

Sealy Baby Firm Rest Antibacterial Waterproof Standard Baby Crib Mattress

Lullaby Earth Healthy Support 2-Stage Crib Mattress Check on Amazon
6. EXTRA-FIRM CHOICE

Serta Perfect Start Dual Sided Premium Recycled Fiber Core Crib Mattress

Delta Children Twinkle Stars Infant & Toddler Mattress  Check on Amazon
7. EXTRA-FIRM CHOICE

Serta Perfect Start Dual Sided Premium Recycled Fiber Core Crib Mattress

Nook Sleep Pure Organic, Non-Toxic Crib Mattress

Check on Amazon
8. MINI-CRIB CHOICE

DaVinci Complete Slumber Mini Crib Mattress

Sealy Flex Cool 2-Stage Crib Mattress Check on Amazon
9. INEXPENSIVE CHOICE

Dream On Me, Orthopedic Firm Foam Standard Crib Mattress

Modera Organic Cotton Crib Mattress  Check on Amazon
10. TOP-RATED CHOICE

Delta Children Twinkle Galaxy Dual Sided Premium Recycled Fiber Core Crib Mattress

Kolcraft Pure Sleep Therapeutic 150 Baby Crib Mattress Check on Amazon

How To Choose The Best Organic Crib Mattress

When you are parents, especially first-timers, a lot of the baby lingo in the mattress world will leave you confused. You will be hearing acronyms like GGC and GOTs and probably scratch your head to understand what in the world do they mean. 

But do not worry. Just because you’re not familiar for the jargon, doesn’t mean you won’t be able to make the purchase. We are here to guide you through just that to help you buy the perfect organic crib mattress for your little one. 

Here’s what you need to know:

Greenguard Certified

When you will navigate through baby mattresses, two terms are going to pop up frequently: Greenguard Certified and Greenguard Gold Certified. 

These are safety certifications awarded by UL since children are more likely to be impacted by hampered indoor air quality. If you spot a mattress that’s Greenguard certified, remain assured that the mattress is tested to produce low chemical emissions. 

A cherry on top is the Greenguard Gold certification, which means the chemical emissions are even lower, especially those of Formaldehyde.

Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS)

The GOTS signifies the mattress’ organic journey, from harvesting of materials until it ends up in your hands. So, it ensures the process was sustainable, the raw materials organic, and the manufacturing was socially responsible to deliver a high quality, eco-friendly baby crib mattress. 

Global Organic Latex Standard (GOLS)

The GOLS is specific to organic latex and latex foam. It goes beyond merely ensuring organic raw material. Instead, it signifies that the mattress was also made while keeping human welfare, safety, health, and sustainability in mind. 

CertiPUR-US Certification

As global warming becomes a major issue in need of consideration, the CertiPUR-US certification for baby crib mattresses makes sure you and your little one play your designated part in helping the world. 

The certification means that foam has been produced without ozone deplete and tested rigorously for emissions, flame retardants, lead, and other VOC emissions.

The 10 Best Organic Crib Mattresses

Now that you know what to look for when picking your little one’s mattress, here’s a list to make the task even easier for you. 

Remember, while it’s not necessary to tick off all these certifications when buying the mattress (because it is going to be a heavy investment then), it’s always a good option to look for some of them. 

Have a look at our top 10 best organic crib mattress picks: 

EDITORS CHOICE
Best Crib Mattress For Newborns

1. Naturepedic Breathable Organic Crib Mattress 252-Coil

As parents, we want to make our child independent from the start. This meaning having them sleep in a crib in their own room. But obviously the thought is a little frightening. What if the baby flips over in the night and can’t flip back?

Catering to these concerns, breathability becomes a prime deciding factor in choosing crib mattresses, and that’s where we loved the Breathable line by Naturepedic! 

The mattress is made with “Breathe-Thru” tech. The mattress pad is made from organic cotton and features a 3D mesh surface which allows the child to breathe, even when faced down. What’s better, and made this mattress seem like the best breathable option, was that the mesh surface can also be removed, washed, and put back. 

In addition, the mattress is non-toxic and free of flame retardants. It is also great for sensitive, fragile children or those with any form of allergy conditions. 

Another feather in the cap for the mattress – it’s dual-sided. One side is extra-firm and perfect for newborns and infants. Once your baby grows up, you can simply flip the mattress to a relatively softer side and have your little one sleeping like, well, a baby, through the night. 

The only downside we could find in this organic crib mattress – the flippable sides aren’t labelled. So, you’d probably have to go by touch and feel to decide which side’s the best for your child’s current stage.

Pros
  • Breathable with breathe-thru tech
  • Washable 3D mesh surface
  • Allergy-free
  • Dual-sided
Cons
  • Some users stated that the sides aren’t labeled. So, choosing the firm and soft side could involve guesswork from your side

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Crib Mattress for Preemie

2. Naturepedic Organic Lightweight Classic Baby & Toddler Mattress

If you are a parent who has to travel often and the baby always come with you, the portability of the Lightweight Classic by Naturepedic will leave you stunned. 

This organic portable crib mattress roughly weighs 2 pounds while the other product lines, such as innerspring, mark at about 18 pounds.

See the difference?! This is because the mattress is created using the Naturepedic patented wavesupport core which makes it strong, durable, and easy to lift. 

The mattress is Greeguard and GOTS certified, keeping chemical emissions at bay. It’s also breathable, giving your baby a safe and healthy sleeping environment.   

Considering that where there is a baby, there are spills and leakages, the mattress also comes with a natural waterproof coating. What is “natural”, you may wonder? The cotton of the mattress has an organic waterproof crib mattress cover created from sugarcane – sustainable and 100% natural. Cleaning this cover becomes a piece of cake. A little soap and water and swipe of the cloth and you’re good to go with a fresh, clean mattress!  

The only downside we could find for this mattress was that while it specifies a snug fit, some users did comment of a few inches less than advertised. While some also commented that the mattress tends to sag in the middle after a few years, the company has supposedly fixed the issue – so that should not be a problem. 

Other than that, you can’t go any more lightweight than this classic! 

Pros
  • Lightweight – about 2 lbs
  • GOTS and Greenguard certified
  • Organic waterproof coating
  • Easy to clean
Cons
  • Some users compared of a slightly smaller size than the standard crib mattress
  • Known to sag a little

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Crib Mattress for Toddlers

3. Organic Dream Organic Cotton Lightweight Mattress

Organic Dream is a brand known to sell non-toxic mattresses. But this one made to our list because of one, unique quality. It is hypoallergenic. 

Made with high quality and 100% certified organic fabric, the mattress cover is made with pure, organic cotton. Being hypoallergenic, it is the perfect fit for sensitive babies and keeps skin reactions, allergies, and other skin conditions at bay. 

The mattress also does not have any chemical smell or doesn’t need airing out, as compared to other, usual organic options. 

This is not all. The mattress also promotes easy breathing. It comes equipped with the Pure-Air 100% Breathable technology and allows the child to sleep soundly throughout the night without any risk of suffocation. 

The tag of Greenguard Gold Certification also puts this mattress slightly above the rest in the list of the best organic crib mattresses. Afterall, the certification is perhaps the highest you can expect your baby’s mattress to be. 

Another plus: The mattress comes with a washable cover. So, no fearing spit-ups and spills anymore. But, it has to be washed in the machine.

A slight downside – the mattress is a bit heavy at 11 pounds.  

Pros
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Greenguard Gold certified
  • Organic cotton, washable cover
  • No chemical smells
Cons
  • The cover needs to be machine-washed
  • The mattress weighs 11 lbs

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Baby Crib Mattress Two-Sided

4. Delta Children Simmons SlumberTime Naturally

If a mattress is truly organic, it is bound to leave a dent in your pocket – no questions asked. But, when we found the Simmons SlumberTime Naturally, we were ecstatic because the dent was barely $100!

Needless to say, we categorize this as one of the best organic crib mattresses on a budget. 

While the mattress is cheap, it doesn’t feel so, at all. It is Greenguard Gold and CertiPUR-US certified, non-toxic, free of flame retardants, formaldehyde, and other chemicals and contaminants. It doesn’t get any safer than this. 

The mattress is made with a plant-based soy foam core. That is, it’s completely natural and organic. What’s better is that it’s dual sided featuring an extra-firm side for newborns and infants and a relatively softer textured side for toddlers and beyond. 

The soy foam core isn’t all. The cover of the mattress is also made with naturally blended woven cotton and therefore, is incredibly easy to clean. Being waterproof and stain resistant makes it the perfect companion for messy babies (i.e., all babies, really). 

The only slight problem we could find in this otherwise great mattress was that the print on it was a little too dark, and so shone through a white sheet. That’s it. Nothing that a darker, or beautifully printed cover won’t fix – so it’s a thumbs up from us!

Pros
  • Pocket-Friendly – less than 100$
  • Greenguard Gold and CertiPUR-US certified
  • Made with plant-based soy foam
  • Dual-sided
  • Waterproof and stain resistant cover
Cons
  • The print on the mattress is a little dark

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Baby Crib Mattress Portable

5. Lullaby Earth Healthy Support 2-Stage Crib Mattress

Another mattress in a reasonable price range while being made with recyclable materials is the Lullaby Earth Healthy Support Mattress.

It features a WaveSupport core, specifically created from recycled polyester and organic materials that meet FDA standards.

It is also Greenguard Gold certified, Formaldehyde free, and validated by Made Safe for using safe ingredients. 

Now that you know the interior of the mattress is safe, let’s get to the outside. The mattress comes with 2 levels of firmness, making it flippable and an investment that will last you through your child’s many stages. The edges of the mattress are seamless, offering firm support and preventing any sort of bacteria build-up while ensuring a snug fit to your baby’s crib. So, there’s no fear of the dangerous 2-finger gap. 

The mattress comes with an organic, waterproof crib mattress cover. However, the cover isn’t exactly breathable. So, if you’ve got a sweaty baby or one that tends to feel hot easily, the cover might not be your best bet. 

All in all, the purchase offers good value for money while being non-toxic and incredibly safe. 

Pros
  • Made from recyclable materials
  • Greenguard Gold and Made Safe certified
  • Dual-sided
  • Waterproof cover
Cons
  • The cover is not breathable and can leave your baby feeling hot or sweaty

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Baby Crib Mattress Breathable

6. Delta Children Twinkle Stars Infant & Toddler Mattress

Another mattress made with recyclable materials that we particularly liked was the Twinkle Stars by Delta Children. It has a firm fiber core and comes with the realization of saving 300 water bottles from the landfill. Really!

The mattress is Greenguard Gold certified, gone through CPSIA testing, and boasts a 7-year warranty! Which is probably a few years too long since your child will probably be out of the crib by 4-ish years of age. 

When we looked it up on the maintenance meter, the mattress shone – again. It comes with a waterproof vinyl cover. While this may not be the quietest, it gets the job done as it prevents any spilled liquids (or diaper mishaps) from seeping into the core of the mattress.

The impressive stain resistance of the mattress is another quality to look forward to. But, we haven’t even come to the best part yet. The mattress weighs merely 9 pounds and is – trust us when we say it – within everyone’s budget! Costing about $60, it was one of the cheapest yet quality mattresses we found.

While it may not tick all the boxes, it did tick enough to make us consider it one of the best organic portable crib mattress.

Pros
  • Budget friendly – Nearly $60!
  • Lightweight – 9 lbs. only
  • Greenguard Gold certified
  • Been through CPSIA testing
  • Waterproof cover
Cons
  • The cover tends to be a little noisy

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Baby Crib Mattress Hypoallergenic

7. Nook Sleep Pure Organic, Non-Toxic Crib Mattress

If you’re fond of aesthetics and want your baby’s room to look the best and brightest, the colorful Nook Sleep Mattress will definitely get you there. It comes in 4 colors – Lilac, Peacock, Pacific, and Sky – and each of them exude style and comfort. 

Let us make this clear: this mattress was on the rather expensive pricey end. But we felt it was absolutely worth the cost. As a Greenguard Gold certified mattress, this one by Nook is incredibly soft, breathable, and displays a beautiful texture. 

Since it’s made by a company based in California, the mattress broadly uses locally sourced, non-toxic materials. It is dual-sided, with the infant side made from organic coconut coir combined skillfully with natural latex foam. While the toddler side is made using rubber tree latex. So, if you wanted something natural, this organic latex crib mattress is the best you can go. 

That’s not all. The mattress comes with washable cover, easily removed via a nylon zipper. The cover is also made from eucalyptus fiber and a company-special, non-toxic poly blend, so the cover’s good to go too! 

One thing that we’re not sure about is whether the colored dyes are natural or not. But they should be, considering it’s a GOTS certified product and certainly worth every penny!

Pros
  • Uses locally sourced, non-toxic materials
  • Comes in multiple colors
  • Washable and removable cover
  • Greenguard Gold certified
Cons
  • The mattress is slightly pricey
  • The source of the dyes has not been specified

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Baby Crib Mattress Organic

8. Sealy Flex Cool 2-Stage Crib Mattress

Extra firm and incredibly durable, the Sealy Flex Cool is valued at less than $100, but it’s worth much more! 

The mattress is made of 204 premium coils – yes, 204! – and contains anti-sag steel bars which give the foam its shape and allow it to maintain firmness for years. Or life. Considering the mattress comes with a lifetime warranty!

The surface of the mattress is waterproof and PVC-free, meaning no noise and no seeping of liquids or more into the mattress’ core. Since it’s Flex Cool 2 Stage, the mattress has an airy and breathable dual-sided design that allows flipping when your child transitions into a toddler. 

Greenguard Gold certified and certainly a budget-friendly option, this mattress gives other alternatives a run for their money. But, some have complained of receiving a slightly stained mattress, so bear that in mind. 

Pros
  • Budget-friendly
  • Dual-sided
  • Breathable
  • Anti-sag
  • Lifetime warranty
Cons
  • Some customers have complained of receiving a slightly stained mattress

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Baby Crib Mattress Affordable

9. Modera Organic Cotton Crib Mattress

Modera might not be a very popular brand in the world of organic crib mattresses, but this mattress left us pleasantly surprised. 

The mattress is breathable, dual-sided, and Certi-PUR US certified. It’s been lab tested for quality and safety assurance and keeps your child away from any harsh chemicals or irritants. It’s also made of cotton, but barely makes a sound as your child sleeps noiselessly through the night.

But that’s not what excited us. This organic cotton crib mattress is plush and moldable! What does this mean, exactly? The ultra-soft, memory foam layer molds itself according to the contours of your child’s body. Thereby helping them improve their posture, relax better, and support body development. 

The cotton cover is also easily washable and can be removed via a zipper. So, you can tick “easy-to-maintain” off the must-have list in your baby’s crib mattress. 

The mattress is also perfectly sized to be a snug fit for the standard crib, which is one less aspect to worry about. But some parents have stated to prefer a topper on the mattress for improved comfort and depth – so keep that in mind.  

Pros
  • Plush and moldable
  • Waterproof zipper cover
  • Noise-free
  • Certi-PUR US certified
Cons
  • Some parents have preferred adding a topper to the mattress

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Baby Crib Mattress Waterproof

10. Kolcraft Pure Sleep Therapeutic 150 Baby Crib Mattress

We saved one of the best for the last. This mattress, costing about $60, comes heavily recommended. Over 2,700+ 5-Star ratings on Amazon to be precise.

The mattress is made with continuous coil and cotton. It’s 150 steel coils provide structure while the cotton adds comfort for the baby.

The fabric is also Greenguard Gold certified and hypoallergenic. 

All of this was alright, but the cover made it even special. Featuring lock-stitched waterproof binding, the cover keeps water, other liquids, and moisture out of the mattress’ core. In case of any spills, it can simply be cleaned with a swipe of a damp cloth.  

The mattress is also pretty lightweight, which makes for easy sheet changes. If your child has a habit of wetting the bed, this one won’t make the aftermath a pain for you. But bear in mind that the dimensions of the mattress are slightly smaller than the standard crib, so you might have to get an organic crib mattress topper or good sheets to go with it.

Pros
  • Affordable
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Waterproof with lock-stitched binding
  • Greenguard Gold certified
  • Lightweight
Cons
  • The mattress is slightly smaller than the standard crib size

Final Verdict 

We’ve given you 10 high-quality options for an organic and non-toxic baby crib mattress. While they’re all great in different categories, one that stood out for us was the Naturepedic Organic Lightweight series (#2).

The mattress is organic – made from sugarcane –, contains multiple certifications, is easy to clean, and incredibly lightweight. All of this ensures it provides the best bang for your buck and becomes the best organic crib mattress for your little one!  

A Suggestion: Since organic mattresses can be heavy on the pocket, you can either invest in one yourself to last the years to come. Or, add it to your baby registry for people to chip in. 

Frequently Asked Questions 

If you’re new in making the transition to sustainable and organic, it’s alright to be confused. 

We’ve answered some of the most common questions:

Since organic crib mattresses are expensive, should I buy a used one?

We would not suggest it. For one, you wouldn’t be sure of how the previous owners had taken care of the mattress and so it could host all sorts of germs and bacteria, that may affect the health of your child. But other than that, safety regulations keep changing. So, getting a recent one would mean updated safety for your child too. 

How much do organic crib mattresses cost?

Usually more than the regular mattress, but the finances vary. They could go from $50+ to over $1000 even! But don’t worry. We’ve got many budget-friendly organic crib mattress brands for you in the list. 

Should we always buy a mattress made in the US?

It is preferred, yes. That’s because the US has stringent laws on mattress manufacturing and stresses upon clearing multiple certifications and quality control tests before being released into the public. 

Do mattresses come with a warranty?

Mostly, yes. These can be up to 10 years, or even last a lifetime, as given by Sealy Flex Cool (#8). 

Leave a Comment