Best Crib Mattress For Tummy Sleepers Review 2022 Buyer Guide

Mattress picking is one of the most difficult choices that parents have to make when setting up the nursery. It is a difficult, yet essential decision. Looking at the choices in the market, with hundreds of brands and hundreds of choices across the world, narrowing down to the best is difficult, however here we provide a list of mattresses that are the best crib mattresses for tummy sleepers on Amazon. 

5 Best Crib Mattress for tummy sleepers

After searching through the web and making our way through thousands of reviews, we’ve created our list of the best crib mattress for tummy sleepers we could find. 

Here are our top picks:


Newton Baby Crib Mattress

Newton Baby Crib Mattress Check on Amazon
2. Premium CHOICE

Serta Perfect Slumber

Serta Perfect Slumber Check on Amazon

Dream On Me Coil Mattress

Dream On Me Coil Mattress  Check on Amazon

Bubble Bear Premium Foam

Bubble Bear Premium Foam Check on Amazon

Naturepedic Organic Classic Crib Mattress for Tummy Sleepers

NSaturepedic Organic Classic Crib Mattress for Tummy Sleepers Check on Amazon

Top 5 Best Crib Mattress for tummy sleepers

Now that you’re equipped with all the baby crib mattress for tummy sleepers knowledge you could want, it’s time to start with the main deal. 

We’ve overtaken the responsibility for you. Here are our top 5 best crib mattress for tummy sleepers:

Best Crib Mattress Protector

1. Newton Baby Crib Mattress

Making the right purchase for a crib mattress for those tummy sleepers is an essential choice and with this mattress, listed as Amazon’s choice you cannot go wrong. Made of breathable technology, this mattress allows the baby to breathe effortlessly should they fall asleep on their faces. 

The foam mattresses are washable and hypoallergenic, meaning in cases of emergencies and accidents, the foam remains intact and safe. This mattress is one of the top choices for tummy sleepers and comes Greenguard certified as well as the pediatrician recommended. 

While the mattress comes highly recommended and appears to be one of the best investments for your baby, the sizing may be a little concerning. While the dimensions provided on amazon may work well for many cribs, having it double-checked will save you time and money. 

Eco-friendly should be the road to take when it concerns your baby, however, with this product, not all materials are as organic as they may seem.

  • Washable
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Greenguard certified
  • Differing sizes
  • Not entirely organic 

 Little One’s Pad Pack ‘N’ Play Mattress Cover

2. Serta Perfect Slumber

GreenGuard gold-certified mattress proves to be waterproof against all accidents and incidents. Made with non-toxic materials the mattress is perfect for tummy sleepers. It has been proven against toxic fire retardants, harmful lead, phthalate, and CPSIA as well. 

As the materials are waterproof, this also means that it is easy to clean and maintain, which is a plus for many new parents. The mattress is also dual-sided which is perfect for when the baby is in their toddler ages. This also proves it to be a great investment. 

While the mattress being waterproof is a plus, it does however makes noise with movement, which can be disturbing for a sleeping baby. 

Mattresses for babies should be more on the firm side rather than soft, however, this foam mattress may be a little too hard at first.  Deciding what the baby needs will make sure you reach an informed purchase decision.

  • GreenGuard certified
  • Waterproof
  • Fire retardant
  • Easy to clean and maintain
  • Dual-sided
  • Maybe a little noisy
  • More on the firm side

Sealy Stain Protection Crib Mattress Pad

3. Dream On Me Coil Mattress

Another one of Amazon Choices, this coil mattress is perfect for a mattress for tummy sleepers. Featuring brown clouds, the coil mattress consists of memory foam, which provides firm and plush support for the baby. 

The dual-sided mattress ensures durability well into toddler years as well. This means it’s worth the investment. It also consists of breathable material. The airflow pockets make sure the mattress is always cool, without the need for small metal vents. 

While coil mattresses are one of the safer choices for infants and toddlers, this mattress while doing that can also be seen as a little flimsy. Meaning that often the softness of the mattress due to the memory foam can form marks on it.

  • Memory foam
  • Dual-sided
  • Breathable material
  • Can form marks
  • The shape and sturdiness of the mattress is not durable

PlushDeluxe Bamboo Crib Mattress Protector

4. Bubble Bear Premium Foam

Safety is the number concern that is taken care of with this mattress. With supportive and sturdy edges, this mattress provides the utmost care for your baby. 

Most mattresses have the same issue when they are unpacked: the smell emitted due to toxins. However, this mattress ensures that there is no smell and is great to be used right away.

Mattresses that are thick provide more stability and softness to your baby. While this mattress may be softer, it lacks the thickness that may be assumed to be the best. However, if you layer the mattress with extra padding, it can provide the perfect night’s sleep as it promises. 

  • Supportive and sturdy edges
  • Ensures safety
  • Not the recommended thickness
  • May emit smell when unpacked

SureGuard Mattress Protector

5. Naturepedic Organic Classic Crib Mattress for Tummy Sleepers

Sustainability is an important feature that this mattress for tummy sleepers offers. Free of toxic materials, this mattress is the ultra safety precaution that a baby needs. 

With heat-sealed waterproof seams, the mattress is not accident-prone. It keeps the damage minimal and wipes clean.  It also ensures that dust mites and bed bugs are not a bother.

The mattress is made of such materials that allow airflow to prevent any form of SIDS, however, this also means that the mattress does not retain any body heat, which can be a negative for infants who would like to sleep on a warm surface. 

  • Sustainable
  • Organic
  • Heat-sealed waterproof seams  
  • Does not retain body heat

Frequently Asked Questions 

1. Does a breathable mattress mean there is no need for extra mattress covers? 

To get the maximum breathable mattress, it is encouraged not to add extra layers for at least the first 12 months of the baby. The mattress itself is made up of such materials that are easy to wash and clean, without worrying about extra layers.

2. Is an organic mattress better than a non-organic mattress? 

There aren’t any 100% organic mattresses. The mattresses are manufactured keeping the baby in mind, so they are safe and certified. The inner core and the plastics, if used are breathable, which makes it better than other mattresses. However, if non-organic are better than organic, then the answer would be no. Even though there isn’t a 100% surety, being safe is recommended. 

3. Can a crib mattress fit a twin bed?

Most mattresses are dual-sided and manufactured keeping in mind the needs of infants and toddlers. So if the mattress can only convert to a toddler’s bed and not a twin bed. 

4. Are Ikea cribs compatible with these mattresses? 

Most mattresses can fit Ikea cribs. However, it would be recommended to keep the sizing in mind at the time of purchase.

5. Is there a need for an extra waterproof sheet despite the mattress being waterproof?

The mattresses are sufficient enough against leakages and accidents, so adding another layer will not be needed. However, adding a sheet cover to allow more comfort is advised. 

Leave a Comment