Best Baby Crib Mattress

Purchasing a crib is an incredibly fun task. You juggle between colors, choose a design, and get the perfect size to adorn your baby’s room. But choosing the best baby crib mattress? Not that fun, we know, but an extremely important part of your child’s growth. 

Considering that your child will be sleeping about 14-17 hours a day as a newborn, their crib mattress will be their best friend during their initial years. They help fix their posture, promote bone development, and provide back support. In addition, the right mattress prevents risks of suffocation or Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS). 

What’s the right mattress? We’ll tell you all about it. 

EDITORS PICK
9.7
Newborns

Newborns

  • Extra-Firm
  • Waterproof
  • Stain-Resistant
  • Greenguard Gold Certified 
OVERALL BEST
9.3
Preemie

Preemie

  • 204 coil count
  • Anti-Sag
  • Hospital-Grade cover
  • Lightweight for a coil mattress
BUDGET PICK
8.5
Toddlers

Toddlers

  • Double-Sided
  • Made with CertiPur certified foam
  • Perfect size for crib and toddler beds
  • Washable cover 

10 Best Baby Crib Mattresses 

Babies need 

Here are the top 10 best crib mattresses that will help you to get a quality mattress at a cheap price.

IMAGE PRODUCT PRICE
1. EDITORS CHOICE

Graco Premium Foam Baby Crib Mattress

Best Crib Mattress For Newborns Check on Amazon
2. PREMIUM CHOICE

Milliard Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic Infant Crib Mattress

Best Crib Mattress for Preemie Check on Amazon
3. BUDGET CHOICE

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Blue Crib Mattress

Best Crib Mattress for Toddlers Check on Amazon
4. CHEAPEST CHOICE

Kolcraft Pure Sleep Therapeutic 150 Waterproof Baby Crib Mattress

Best Baby Crib Mattress Two-Sided Check on Amazon
5. ANTIBACTERIAL CHOICE

Sealy Baby Firm Rest Antibacterial Waterproof Standard Baby Crib Mattress

Best Baby Crib Mattress Portable Check on Amazon
6. EXTRA-FIRM CHOICE

Serta Perfect Start Dual Sided Premium Recycled Fiber Core Crib Mattress

Best Baby Crib Mattress Breathable Check on Amazon
7. EXTRA-FIRM CHOICE

Serta Perfect Start Dual Sided Premium Recycled Fiber Core Crib Mattress

Best Baby Crib Mattress Breathable Check on Amazon
8. MINI-CRIB CHOICE

DaVinci Complete Slumber Mini Crib Mattress

Best Baby Crib Mattress Organic Check on Amazon
9. INEXPENSIVE CHOICE

Dream On Me, Orthopedic Firm Foam Standard Crib Mattress

Best Baby Crib Mattress Affordable Check on Amazon
10. TOP-RATED CHOICE

Delta Children Twinkle Galaxy Dual Sided Premium Recycled Fiber Core Crib Mattress

Best Baby Crib Mattress Waterproof Check on Amazon

Crib Mattress vs Toddler Mattress – What’s The Buzz?

The first step to getting the best baby crib mattress is knowing exactly what age you’re looking for. While there aren’t any major differences between what we call the crib mattress against a toddler’s mattress, there is one essential distinction: the level of firmness. 

Infants, newborns, and preemies require an extra firm surface that helps keep them straight, flat, and unable to sink in. This helps develop their bones and prevents any risk of cradling, sagging, or going in. Conversely, a toddler mattress can be on a slightly softer side. In fact, some toddlers may even want it to be so.  

In addition, you wouldn’t want to put any sheets or pillows on a crib mattress for fear that your child could roll onto them facedown and be unable to breathe and risk suffocation. The same concerns don’t resonate with a toddler. 

If you’re trying to amp up your little toddler’s crib, you can go all out with the crib and mattress design!

How To Choose The Best Mattress For A Baby Crib?

When you enter a mattress shop, complex baby jargon will be thrown at you nonchalantly. As terms like breathable, dual-sided, Greenguard Gold certified, and hypoallergenic fill the air, it is okay to feel confused. Or if you are first-timer parents, then we’d be surprised if you weren’t confused. 

But do not worry. We’ll tell you the mattress essentials.

The best type of mattress for a baby crib depends upon, first and foremost, how old is your child. Newborns and infants require safer, breathable, and extra-firm mattresses to aid support and prevent suffocation in case they flip to their stomachs during the night. On the other hand, toddlers and little kids can get a restful sleep with slightly softer mattresses too. 

Here are a few things to consider:

Hypoallergenic 

As newborns, your baby is susceptible to catching the slightest of infections due to the currently developing immune system. This means allergies can happen.

Therefore, some mattresses are made with anti-allergy covers, allergen protectants, and dust-mite-resistant fabrics to prevent your child from sneezing the night away.

Breathable Material

For babies that have learned to roll over, a breathable mattress is a savior. 

The breathability basically means your child can breathe through the mattress due to sufficient airflow, as well as remain protected from sweaty backs or extreme aspects like SIDS. 

Safe For Usage

Of course, when the matter is of a child, safety remains one of the top priorities. This is why mattresses are supposed to meet a set of flammability standards to prevent them from catching fire at the slightest of ignition. The dimensions of the baby crib mattress must also match those of the crib to prevent the danger of SIDS. Even a two-finger space can wreak havoc.

Durable

In the baby world, durability means how long you can use the mattress for. However, the need of the child differs between the phases of infancy to toddlers and beyond. Therefore, a durable mattress would be flippable, i.e., dual-sided, featuring two stages of firmness. This way, the mattress can be used for your newborn and flipped over when your baby grows.   

Our Top 10 Best Baby Crib Mattresses 

Now that you know everything vital there is to know about baby mattresses, you are fully equipped to get into the market and purchase one for your little one. Or, if you trust us and need a little ease, we can tell you about the best baby crib mattress Amazon. 

Have a look at our top picks:

EDITORS CHOICE
Best Crib Mattress For Newborns

1. Best Crib Mattress For Newborns: Safety 1st Crib and Toddler Mattress

Newborns require a firm mattress that provides them with support without running the risk of suffocation or sinking. The Safety 1st baby crib mattress, as its name entails, does that for you. 

It comes in the standard crib dimensions of 52×27.5×5 inches. So, you can rule out the risk of your baby’s hand getting caught between the crib and the mattress. Its core is made from thermo-bonded polyester fiber that forms an ultra-firm surface for support. Yet again, another imperative aspect for newborns. 

As a feather in its hat (or mattress cover?), this is the best infant mattress for crib also because its vinyl cover is waterproof and stain-resistant. So, even if there are spit-ups in the night or a few diaper accidents, you can simply wipe the surface clean with soap and water. 

The downside: the cover is vinyl, so it isn’t the most comfortable. But it’s nothing that a good mattress topper won’t solve. Also, the mattress has a 50 pounds weight capacity, so bear that in mind when purchasing. 

The Great

  • Extra-Firm
  • Waterproof
  • Stain-Resistant
  • Greenguard Gold Certified 

The Not-So-Good

  • The vinyl cover is not very comfortable
  • The weight limitation is 50 lbs

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Crib Mattress for Preemie

2. Best Crib Mattress for Preemie: Sealy Baby Firm Rest

When your little one is born before time, you must be extra careful with everything. This includes the choice of the crib mattress. The Sealy Baby Firm Rest is a coil mattress that is lighter than the rest, weighing 13 pounds but is firm enough to support your child’s development. 

The mattress has a high, 204 coil count and bordered edges that keep it flat and firm. While its amazing anti-sag system ensures your baby’s weight is distributed evenly and the little premature one does not sink in. 

The Sealy Firm Rest is also Greenguard Gold Certified and comes with a hospital-grade, hypoallergenic cover. This is absolutely critical for premature babies as it creates an all-over healthy environment in the crib. 

However, the cover is known to be slightly crinkly and therefore noisy. This can be a little problem for light sleepers. 

The Great

  • 204 coil count
  • Anti-Sag
  • Hospital-Grade cover
  • Lightweight for a coil mattress

The Not-So-Good

  • Known to have a noisy cover

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Crib Mattress for Toddlers

3. Best Crib Mattress for Toddlers: Milliard Memory Foam Crib Mattress

If your little one has reached the toddler stage, there’s a high chance that they’d want a bed instead of a crib. This mattress by Milliard is exactly made for you then. 

The mattress fits the dimensions of a crib while also proving to be a perfect fit for the usual crib mattress toddler bed. Being double-sided also helps because the mattress has softer memory foam for toddlers and firmer foam for infants on the other side.

So, you can buy the mattress during infancy and as your little one grows, you can simply flip it over and into a new, toddler bed. Your child can rest in the familiar embrace of its mattress while getting the right support for growth. 

The mattress also has a 100% cotton cover. This makes it waterproof and completely washable for if (read: when) accidents occur. However, since it’s cotton, the cover does run the risk of shrinking a little when washed, so you would need to be prepared for that.

The Great

  • Double-Sided
  • Made with CertiPur certified foam
  • Perfect size for crib and toddler beds
  • Washable cover 

The Not-So-Good

  • Cotton cover can shrink when washed

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Baby Crib Mattress Two-Sided

4. Best Baby Crib Mattress Two-Sided: Moonlight Baby Little Dreamer Crib Mattress

If you love the idea of a dual-sided crib mattress, you will love the Little Dreamer. This mattress comes from one of the more popular baby crib mattress brands and features two sides to its surface. One consists of extra-firm foam for infants, while the other has softer, plush foam for toddlers. 

However, this isn’t the only quality of the mattress. This one’s a complete delight as it is odor resistant, water-resistant, easy to clean, dust mite resistant, and consists of a woven fire barrier! So basically, it provides coverage for most kinds of mishaps you could imagine for a child. 

It’s also one of the lightest dual-sided baby crib mattresses you will find in the market, weighing merely 7.7 pounds. However, this baby crib mattress costs a little higher than usual, so it’s not the most pocket-friendly option out there.

The Great

  • Double-Sided
  • Lightweight at 7.7 lbs
  • Odor/stain/water resistan
  • Bed bug and dust mites resistant

The Not-So-Good

  • Comparatively expensive

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Baby Crib Mattress Portable

5. Best Baby Crib Mattress Portable: Lullaby Earth Breathe Safe Mini Crib Mattress

If you like to always keep your little one close to you, getting a portable crib mattress is the way to go. This one by Lullaby Earth weighs merely 6.34 pounds and fits most standard mini cribs. Place it inside the crib or with you as a play pad, and your child will always be in the best of spirits. 

In addition to being lightweight, the mattress is also health-friendly. It comes with a mattress protector following a distinct, 3-D design. This basically guarantees airflow within the fabric to ensure your child does not run the risk of suffocation. 

However, since the mattress is purpose-built for infants, the firmness level runs high. If you wish for a flippable mattress or one that goes a little soft, this might not fit the bill.

The Great

  • Lightweight
  • Organic 
  • Breathable
  • Waterproof 

The Not-So-Good

  • Relatively stiff

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Baby Crib Mattress Breathable

6. Best Baby Crib Mattress Breathable: Newton Baby Crib Mattress

This mattress takes the term “breathable” to a whole new level. 

Perfect for kids who are tummy sleepers, the mattress is proposed to be 100% breathable, courtesy of its unique, breathe-thru technology. As the airflow within is maximized, it limits the risk of CO2 breathing or suffocation for your child.

But that’s not all. What pleasantly surprised us was that this mattress is completely washable – cover to core. No kidding. There is no hassle with foam, latex, or any kind of springs. Simply throw the cover in the wash and the core in a tub and rinse the two for a completely new and clean mattress to adorn the crib.

The icing on the cake is that this mattress is two-sided. So, it is the best crib mattress for newborns as well as toddlers. However, it does weigh a little on the higher side – 11

The Great

  • 100% breathable
  • Completely washable – cover to core
  • Dual-sided

The Not-So-Good

  • Weighs heavy 

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Baby Crib Mattress Hypoallergenic

7. Best Baby Crib Mattress Hypoallergenic: Milliard Hypoallergenic Foam Crib Mattress

This Milliard mattress stays true to its brand’s ideology of “safety-first”. The mattress is anti-inflammable and created with CertiPUR certified foam. 

It is of the perfect firmness with pediatrician-recommended 28D foam that works great for almost all levels of babies. The mattress provides support and cradles the child while ensuring they do not sink in and risk suffocation. 

In case your child is a light sleeper and moves about a lot during the night, this mattress can also be its perfect companion. It has a 100% waterproof, quiet cover. Not only does it wipe clean easily, but it also does not crinkle while your baby snoozes. So, you know the naps and night Zzzs will be good, and probably give you a little time to relax too. 

However, considering it is a foam mattress, it does take a few days to expand and puff up to size so it would not be available for use as soon as it arrives.   

The Great

  • Hypoallergenic
  • No noise covers
  • Waterproof encasement
  • Inexpensive 

The Not-So-Good

  • Takes a few days to expand and gain shape

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Baby Crib Mattress Organic

8. Best Baby Crib Mattress Organic: Naturepedic Baby Organic Lightweight Classic

This one also made it to our list of the best crib mattress for preemies and infants, but we figured its organic quality triumphs over others. After all, this was one of the very few mattresses that was 100% GOTS certified, passed all flammability requirements, and was made with organic cotton. 

The waterproof coating of the mattress is also made from sugarcane, making this product completely natural and effortlessly easy to clean. A little soap and water would do the trick. The mattress also comes pediatrician recommended with an extra-firm surface that supports infant and preemie growth and bone development. 

Given the numerous qualities of the mattress, it weighing merely 1 pound seems too good to be true. But it really is! However, it does hint at the high price of the mattress, which can be considered a little too high for a mattress with one level of firmness. 

The Great

  • Organic
  • Extra-Firm
  • 100% GOTS certified
  • Lightweight
  • Easy to clean

The Not-So-Good

  • Expensive
  • One firmness level

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Baby Crib Mattress Affordable

9. Best Baby Crib Mattress Affordable: Dream On Me Innerspring Crib And Toddler Mattress

Buying a crib mattress is a slight burden on the pocket. So, you probably won’t believe us when we tell you all that Dream On Me has to offer with this mattress, at a mere baby crib mattress cost of $50! 

Let’s begin. The mattress is made with 88 coils, so you know it is extra firm for your child. It is Greenguard Gold certified and comes with a 10-year warranty. 

The mattress also has a dual-sided cushion, keeping your child comfortable – always. In addition, it keeps an eye out for the usual leakages and accidents with its easy-to-wipe mattress. 

Yes, the mattress is comparatively heavy to others at a weight of 12 pounds. But, considering it’s the perfect fit for standard crib sizes and under the $100 level – it’s a steal! And apparently, most users agree as the mattress has 7900+ reviews with approximately 80% with a 5-Star rating! 

The Great

  • Pocket friendly
  • Firm
  • Easy to clean 

The Not-So-Good

  • Weighs heavy

PREMIUM CHOICE
Best Baby Crib Mattress Waterproof

10. Best Baby Crib Mattress Waterproof: Serta Tranquility Eco Firm

It is quite difficult to find a mattress that is waterproof as well as safe for baby usage. This is because many brands involve the usage of chemicals to give a mattress its water-resistant tendencies. But not Serta. 

This mattress does not use any harmful chemicals for testing. It exceeds flammability requirements as well as CPSIA testing. Its waterproof vinyl cover with a perimeter border wire helps the mattress maintain its shape while being a piece of cake to clean.

The Serta Eco Firm comes with 120 heavy-duty coils, which make it a little heavier than the rest at about 16 lbs. However, the support it provides is unmatched. In addition, it is also dual-sided with a cotton layer on its toddler side to add to its plushness. This makes it a great soft crib mattress for toddlers as well as the right firmness for an infant

The Great

  • Waterproof
  • No chemicals 
  • Double-Sided

The Not-So-Good

  • Weighs heavy 

Editor’s Choice: Best Mattress For A Baby Crib 

For us, the best baby crib mattress is one that ticks most of the right boxes without being too heavy on the pocket. Therefore, we’d have to rule in favor of the Newton Baby Crib Mattress (#6). It is dual-sided, breathable, easy-to-clean, and completely safe for usage while being affordable too. A complete win from our side! 

Frequently Asked Questions 

Even after this comprehensive guide, if your mind is still boggled by a few crib mattress-related questions – it’s okay. 

In fact, it’s very common. Find the answers to your questions below:

How do I choose a mattress for my baby?

The best mattress for your baby is one with a firm and flat surface that supports the child’s body instead of letting it sink in and risk SIDS. 

What is the best mattress for a baby crib?

One that fits the dimensions completely and fulfills your requirements. These could be any: breathability, waterproof, hypoallergenic, etc.  

Which crib mattress is the best for a baby?

This depends on the category of mattresses you are looking for. Our guide gives the best mattress (to our research) for many such categories. 

What is the best crib mattress for infants?

Infants require a mattress with an extra-firm surface as well as a breathable interior to prevent any hindered breathing. 

Leave a Comment